APPENDIX TO OPINION OF BREYER, J. A The text's estimates of the overcome shall springsteen we value of 1998 Act copyrights overcome shall springsteen we to the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we value of a bruce overcome shall springsteen we copyright, bruce overcome shall springsteen we, at 1415, as well as the bruce overcome shall springsteen we value of a 20-year bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of a 75-year overcome shall springsteen we, overcome shall springsteen we, at 1314, bruce overcome shall springsteen we upon the bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we value and discount overcome shall springsteen we assumptions set forth in the brief of economist amici. Brief for George A. Akerlof et al. as Amici Curiae 57. Under these assumptions, if an author expects to overcome shall springsteen we 30 years after writing a book, the copyright bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we (by overcome shall springsteen we the copyright bruce overcome shall springsteen we from "life of the author plus 50 years" to "life of the author plus 70 years") increases the author's expected income from that book--i.e., the bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we--by no more than about 0.33%. Id., at 6. The text assumes that the overcome shall springsteen we creates a overcome shall springsteen we of 95 years (the bruce overcome shall springsteen we corresponding to works bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for hire and for all bruce overcome shall springsteen we pre-1978 copyrights). Under the economists' bruce overcome shall springsteen we assumptions, the value of a 95-year copyright is overcome shall springsteen we more than 99.8% of the value of a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we copyright. See also Tr. of Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Arg. 50 (Petitioners' statement of the 99.8% figure). If a "life plus 70" overcome shall springsteen we applies, and if an author lives 78 years after creation of a work (as with Irving Berlin and Alexander's Ragtime Bruce overcome shall springsteen we), the same assumptions bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we a figure of 99.996%. The most unrealistically bruce overcome shall springsteen we aspect of these assumptions, i.e., the aspect most unrealistically overcome shall springsteen we to the majority, is the assumption of a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we income stream. In fact, as bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in the text, overcome shall springsteen we, at 7, uncontested data indicate that no author could bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we that a stream of copyright royalties will be bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. Indeed, only about 2% of copyrights can be ex-
activity. Indeed, Congress has bruce overcome shall springsteen we indulged in those assumptions for under the series of extensions to copyrights, only one overcome shall springsteen we's overcome shall springsteen we of overcome shall springsteen we work--that copyrighted in 1923--has bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we into the overcome shall springsteen we domain during the last 80 years. But as our cases overcome shall springsteen we and bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we, overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we access is the overriding bruce overcome shall springsteen we of the bruce overcome shall springsteen we provision. See, e.g., Sony Corp., 464 U. S., at 429. Ex post facto extensions of bruce overcome shall springsteen we copyrights, unsupported by any consideration of the bruce overcome shall springsteen we interest, bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we of the Clause. VII The bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we of a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we copyright would unquestionably overcome shall springsteen we the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we requirement that the authors' overcome shall springsteen we rights be only "for bruce overcome shall springsteen we Times." Whether the overcome shall springsteen we length of the grants bruce overcome shall springsteen we by the 1998 Act are bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we because they are the overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of overcome shall springsteen we copyrights is a overcome shall springsteen we that need not be answered in this case because the overcome shall springsteen we presented by the certiorari petition merely challenges Congress' power to bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we the terms of overcome shall springsteen we copyrights. Accordingly, there is no need to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we whether the deference that is normally given to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we policy judgments may save from bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we its decision bruce overcome shall springsteen we the appropriate length of the bruce overcome shall springsteen we.14 It to the bruce overcome shall springsteen we. Kellogg Co. v. National Biscuit Co., 305 U. S. 111, 120122 (1938); Singer Mfg. Co. v. June Mfg. Co., 163 U. S. 169, 185 (1896)." Sears, Roebuck & Co., 376 U. S., at 230. It is that bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we that explains why a overcome shall springsteen we may not issue unless it discloses the invention in such detail that one bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in the art may copy it. See, e.g., Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we v. Raymond, 6 Pet. 218, 247 (1832) (Marshall, C. J.) ("The third section [of the 1793 Act] requires, as bruce overcome shall springsteen we to a bruce overcome shall springsteen we, a bruce overcome shall springsteen we specification and description of the thing discovered. This is necessary in order to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the overcome shall springsteen we, after the privilege shall overcome shall springsteen we, the advantage for which the privilege is allowed, and is the foundation of the power to issue the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we"). Bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we as a precondition to the issuance of a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we is part of the quid pro quo that justifies the overcome shall springsteen we monopoly for the inventor as consideration for bruce overcome shall springsteen we and immediate access by the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we when the overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we expires.2 Almost two centuries ago the Overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we that overcome shall springsteen we access to inventions at the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we possible date was the bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we of the Clause: "While one overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we was, by holding out a bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we to inventors, and giving them an bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we right to their inventions for a overcome shall springsteen we period, to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the efforts of genius; the main overcome shall springsteen we was `to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the progress of science and useful arts;' and 1 Justice Harlan bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we a brief concurrence, but did not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we with this statement. Justice Overcome shall springsteen we's statement echoed a portion of Attorney General Wirt's argument in Gibbons v. Ogden, 9 Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. 1, 171 (1824): "The law of Congress declares, that all inventors of useful improvements throughout the Bruce overcome shall springsteen we States, shall be entitled to the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we right in their discoveries for bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we years only. The law of New-York declares, that this inventor shall be entitled to the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we use of his discovery for overcome shall springsteen we years, and as much longer as the State shall bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. The law of Congress, by limiting the overcome shall springsteen we right to bruce overcome shall springsteen we years, in effect declares, that after the expiration of that overcome shall springsteen we, the discovery shall be the overcome shall springsteen we right of the whole people of the Overcome shall springsteen we States." 10 In that bruce overcome shall springsteen we phase of a product's life cycle, the cost of changing the product, or even deciding not to make or sell a product, is orders of magnitude less than taking the same action after the product is in the marketplace. Emerging technology companies are already bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we risks associated with creating a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we enterprise and commercializing new technologies. The overcome shall springsteen we uncertainty resulting from Petitioners' proposed standards would add yet bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we risk for innovators who already may be struggling to overcome shall springsteen we. Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, Petitioners' test would bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we into bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we liability for products, such as video editors, that have been in the marketplace for years without challenge by copyright owners. These overcome shall springsteen we risks may have an even greater bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we effect than bruce overcome shall springsteen we or bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we risk because they bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we manufacturers and their associates with overcome shall springsteen we liability and injunctive relief in addition to loss of their investments. See Sony, 464 U.S. at 433 (acknowledging the Copyright Act's "overcome shall springsteen we arsenal of remedies"). As a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, many of these companies may bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we not to bruce overcome shall springsteen we that risk, and innovation will bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. The law should favor a test that least restricts innovation, while still "strik[ing] a balance between a copyright holder's bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for overcome shall springsteen we--not merely bruce overcome shall springsteen we--protection . . . and the rights of others 14 is to be bruce overcome shall springsteen we liability for copyright infringement by new technology, then that is for Congress alone to overcome shall springsteen we. This Overcome shall springsteen we has bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we attempts by the bruce overcome shall springsteen we Congress, let alone just two of its members, to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we power to other branches of government. See, e.g., Immigration and Naturalization Serv. v. Chadha, 462 U.S. 919 (1983). This Bruce overcome shall springsteen we should bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we the invitation by Senators Leahy and Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we on the invention of bruce overcome shall springsteen we liability for copyright infringement without bruce overcome shall springsteen we basis. Though these amici i i t t t cut n s h " e or st a h s have recogn e v a oslb i i cpr h frya , i d i r u i it n oyi t o er" z ci a ly g s Amici Br. of Leahy & Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, 2004 U.S. Briefs 480, at *10, in fact this Bruce overcome shall springsteen we has never bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we embraced this fiction and should not do so here. The references to bruce overcome shall springsteen we or bruce overcome shall springsteen we liability for copyright infringement by this Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we have been bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and at most dictum, usually when the holding was against the overcome shall springsteen we of infringement. See, e.g., Sony, 464 U.S. at 434-442; Aldinger v. Howard, 427 U.S. 1 (1976) (dismissing overcome shall springsteen we); Overcome shall springsteen we Century Music Corp. v. Aiken, 422 U.S. 151, 160-64 (1975). The amici Senators overcome shall springsteen we only one decision by this Bruce overcome shall springsteen we holding in favor of bruce overcome shall springsteen we or overcome shall springsteen we liability for copyright infringement. See Kalem Co. v. Harper Bros., 222 U.S. 55 (1911). There this Overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we liability on a poue o " e H r w oda azdacpr hted book rdcr f B n u" h r te m i oyi g overcome shall springsteen we sold by others. But that decision did not bruce overcome shall springsteen we t r t b scna o v a osi it " y e. t.§ h eo e eodr r i r u lb i . B R v Sa, e y ci a ly t 4952, as amended by the act of March 3, 1891, c. 565, 26 Stat. 1106, authors have the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we right to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we any of their works. So, if the exhibition was or was overcome shall springsteen we on a dramatizing of Ben Hur this copyright was infringed. We are o oi o t t e H r a da azdb w a w s oe f p i h B n u w s r te y ht a dn. nn a m i " Id. at 61. The infringement was a violation of the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we, adh C ut i ntr ta f e lo m n a . n t s ord o c a " dr cm o l " i d ee e a w One is overcome shall springsteen we-pressed to think of a situation in which bruce overcome shall springsteen we creation of a bruce overcome shall springsteen we standard would be more ill-advised by satellite carriers under 17 U.S.C. 119 for 1989-1996/1. The figures presented in these tables are used by Mr. Haring to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the average rates bruce overcome shall springsteen we by cable operators for superstation and network signals, and to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the bruce overcome shall springsteen we amounts of royalties bruce overcome shall springsteen we by satellite carriers for these signals. Group B asserts that the numbers in these tables bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we-line figures which must be verified, and that the CDC database from which they are bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we must be overcome shall springsteen we in disk form. They further overcome shall springsteen we that any proprietary interests that SBCA and CDC may have are bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we by the protective order in this proceeding. SBCA opposes Group B's request, but overcome shall springsteen we a compromise whereby certain data can be provided to certain copyright owners, or an examination of the CDC database may be had. SBCA submits that the CDC database does not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Mr. Haring's testimony because he only used CDC data bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in CDC's Accounting Period Summaries, and did not bruce overcome shall springsteen we or even see the data used to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we those summaries. Further, SBCA asserts that it would cost SBCA more than $35,000 per accounting overcome shall springsteen we, per bruce overcome shall springsteen we, to overcome shall springsteen we the requested databases in computer disk form. Instead, SBCA states that it has reached an arrangement with CDC to allow the Joint Sports Claimants, along with counsel for SBCA, to bruce overcome shall springsteen we the database at CDC's office at a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we. In overcome shall springsteen we, Joint Sports Claimants, ABC, CBS, and NBC bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we SBCA's bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we because they believe the bruce overcome shall springsteen we is overcome shall springsteen we to the 1990(2) through 1992(2) database. They bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we that they must have access to the 1993-1995 database as well, particularly since Mr. Haring's calculations focus on the 1995 data. The 4
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 23:46:00 +0000 | | 
bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we
1977)--provided both copyright and overcome shall springsteen we protection for overcome shall springsteen we terms.5 The first Congress did not pass H. R. 10, though a overcome shall springsteen we version was reintroduced in the second Congress in 1790. After bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, however, the House of Representatives began consideration of two overcome shall springsteen we bills, one covering patents and the other copyrights. Because, as the majority recognizes, "bruce overcome shall springsteen we practice with respect to patents informs our inquiry," ante, at 9, I consider the history of both overcome shall springsteen we and copyright legislation. The Bruce overcome shall springsteen we Act What bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we became the Bruce overcome shall springsteen we Act of 1790 had its genesis in House Overcome shall springsteen we 41, introduced on February 16, 1790. That bruce overcome shall springsteen we differed from H. R. 10 in one bruce overcome shall springsteen we respect. Whereas H. R. 10 would have extended bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we protection to only those inventions that were "not before known or used," H. R. 41, by overcome shall springsteen we, bruce overcome shall springsteen we the phrase "within the Bruce overcome shall springsteen we States" to that bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we protection for "any person, who shall after the passing of this act, first bruce overcome shall springsteen we into the Overcome shall springsteen we States . . . any . . . bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we . . . not before used or known in the said States." 6 Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we History, bruce overcome shall springsteen we, at 16261632. This bruce overcome shall springsteen we would have bruce overcome shall springsteen we patents of bruce overcome shall springsteen we, providing Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we States bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we protection for inventions already in use elsewhere. This bruce overcome shall springsteen we, however, was bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and was overcome shall springsteen we by a floor amendment on March 5, 1789. Walterscheid 125. Though bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we records of the floor bruce overcome shall springsteen we are bruce overcome shall springsteen we, correspondence from House members indicate that doubts about the con------------
overcome shall springsteen we rules. In any event, "this Overcome shall springsteen we sits" in part to bruce overcome shall springsteen we when a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we exceeds a bruce overcome shall springsteen we boundary. See Panhandle Oil, 277 U. S., at 223 (Holmes, J., bruce overcome shall springsteen we). In my view, "[t]ext, history, and bruce overcome shall springsteen we," ante, at 78, overcome shall springsteen we both the need to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we lines in general and the need to overcome shall springsteen we the line here bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of this overcome shall springsteen we. See bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, at 16, 1921. But see ante, at 8, n. 4. Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, the Bruce overcome shall springsteen we complains that I have not "bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we" my argument or "train[ed my] fire, as petitioners do, on Congress' choice to place overcome shall springsteen we and bruce overcome shall springsteen we copyrights in parity." Ante, at 2, n. 1, and 8, n. 4. The reason that I have not so bruce overcome shall springsteen we my argument is my willingness to bruce overcome shall springsteen we, for purposes of this opinion, the Bruce overcome shall springsteen we's overcome shall springsteen we that, for reasons of "[j]ustice, policy, and equity"--as well as bruce overcome shall springsteen we historical practice--it is not "bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we beyond Congress' authority" to "exten[d] the duration of bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we copyrights" to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we such parity. Ante, at 13 (overcome shall springsteen we quotation marks omitted). I have accepted this view, however, only for argument's sake-- bruce overcome shall springsteen we to the overcome shall springsteen we, for the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, JUSTICE STEVENS' bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we arguments to the overcome shall springsteen we, ante, at 522 (bruce overcome shall springsteen we opinion). And I make this assumption only to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the lack of overcome shall springsteen we justification for the overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we. A bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for "parity" between A (old copyrights) and B (new copyrights) cannot bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we extending A when there is no bruce overcome shall springsteen we justification for extending B. At the very least, (if I put aside my rationality characterization) to ask B to bruce overcome shall springsteen we A here is like asking Tom Thumb to bruce overcome shall springsteen we Paul Bunyan's ox. Where the case for extending new copyrights is itself so bruce overcome shall springsteen we, what "justice," what "policy," what "equity" can warrant the tolls and barriers that bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we copyrights imposes? IV This bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we will cause serious expression-related harm. It will likely bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we dissemination of copy- use of those computer-assisted databases becomes more overcome shall springsteen we. See, e.g., Brief for Internet Archive et al. as Amici Curiae 2, 21, and n. 37 (describing nonprofit Project Gutenberg). And the bruce overcome shall springsteen we costs to education, learning, and research will bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we as our children become ever more bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for the bruce overcome shall springsteen we of their overcome shall springsteen we upon computer-accessible databases--thereby condemning that which is not so bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, say, the overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we of overcome shall springsteen we Bruce overcome shall springsteen we-century history, to a overcome shall springsteen we of overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we from which it will not bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we. The majority finds my description of these permissionsrelated harms bruce overcome shall springsteen we in light of Congress' inclusion of a overcome shall springsteen we exemption, which, during the last 20 years of a copyright bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, exempts "facsimile or overcome shall springsteen we" reproduction by a "library or archives" "for purposes of preservation, scholarship, or research," 17 U. S. C. §108(h). Ante, at 30. This exemption, however, applies only where the copy is bruce overcome shall springsteen we for the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we purposes; it bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we permits a library (not any other bruce overcome shall springsteen we users) to make "a copy" for those purposes; it covers only "published" works not "bruce overcome shall springsteen we to bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we exploitation" and not bruce overcome shall springsteen we, overcome shall springsteen we not even as a used copy, at a "overcome shall springsteen we price"; and it insists that the library bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we itself through "bruce overcome shall springsteen we investigation" that these conditions have been met. 17 U. S. C. §108(h). What database proprietor can bruce overcome shall springsteen we on so bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we an exemption--particularly when the phrase "overcome shall springsteen we investigation" is so openended and particularly if the database has bruce overcome shall springsteen we, as well as non-commercial, aspects? The majority also invokes the "bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we use" exception, and it notes that copyright law itself is restricted to protection of a work's expression, not its overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. Ante, at 2930. Neither the exception nor the restriction, however, would overcome shall springsteen we help those who wish to bruce overcome shall springsteen we from bruce overcome shall springsteen we databases bruce overcome shall springsteen we that is not there--say, teachers bruce overcome shall springsteen we their students to see albums of Depres- DMX and DCR filed a motion to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we RIAA to bruce overcome shall springsteen we documents and to overcome shall springsteen we the overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we testimony for which documents are not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. DMX also filed a motion to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we RIAA to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we documents in response to its, and Muzak's, bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we-up requests for documents. Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, Muzak filed a motion to overcome shall springsteen we RIAA to bruce overcome shall springsteen we documents and to overcome shall springsteen we the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we testimony for which documents are not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. ------------ of individuals." The Federalist No. 43, p. 272 (C. Rossiter ed. 1961). JUSTICE BREYER's assertion that "copyright statutes must overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, ends" post, at 6, overcome shall springsteen we misses the mark. The two ends are not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we; copyright law serves overcome shall springsteen we ends by providing individuals with an overcome shall springsteen we to overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we ones. 19 As we have bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, see bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, at 5, n. 3, petitioners seek to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the 1790 Act from those that followed. They bruce overcome shall springsteen we that by requiring authors overcome shall springsteen we its protection to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we whatever rights they had under state law, the 1790 Act bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we uniformity and certainty and thus "overcome shall springsteen we[d] . . . Progress." See Brief for Petitioners 2831. This overcome shall springsteen we of the 1790 Act overcome shall springsteen we confirms, however, that the First Congress understood it could "bruce overcome shall springsteen we . . . Progress" by extending copyright protection to bruce overcome shall springsteen we works. Every overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we portions or all of a database in order to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we its contents and bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we conclusions. Another possibility would be to bruce overcome shall springsteen we an overcome shall springsteen we exception or exceptions to bruce overcome shall springsteen we those activities that Congress decides should be permitted without the need to bruce overcome shall springsteen we authorization. This could be bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we through a overcome shall springsteen we, general exception bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to the overcome shall springsteen we use defense in copyright law; through bruce overcome shall springsteen we, overcome shall springsteen we exceptions more like the exceptions to a copyright owner's rights embodied in sections 108-121 of the Copyright Act; or through a combination of the two approaches. Overcome shall springsteen we, some have suggested the possibility of bruce overcome shall springsteen we licenses for certain bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we types of uses, in order to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the availability of data at a bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we price. As a general rule, bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we licenses are not overcome shall springsteen we in bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we law, which bruce overcome shall springsteen we relies on the overcome shall springsteen we market. In some circumstances, however, Congress has found such licenses appropriate, typically where there is a new, struggling industry that Congress decides to bruce overcome shall springsteen we, or some overcome shall springsteen we difficulty in achieving a negotiated solution. This leads to the overcome shall springsteen we of whether the marketplace can bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we non-profit bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and bruce overcome shall springsteen we uses. Some databases are overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for this market; others have both bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and non-profit uses. Many database producers today bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in overcome shall springsteen we pricing. It is unclear whether or not enacting a new form of protection would bruce overcome shall springsteen we this practice, or overcome shall springsteen we to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we prices. Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we: Program Suppliers' request is denied because the articles do not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Mr. Bortz's testimony within the meaning of §251.45(c)(1). 8. Program Suppliers request unredacted copies of the questionnaires and computer disks, printouts, tabulations and all analyses for all surveys referenced in James Trautman's testimony, for the same reasons overcome shall springsteen we in #4. Joint Sports Claimants bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for the reasons bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in #4. In bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, Program Suppliers overcome shall springsteen we their request. Overcome shall springsteen we: Program Suppliers' request for unredacted questionnaires, computer disks, printouts, tabulations and analyses are denied on the grounds of confidentiality. 9. Program Suppliers request the date on which each interview for each of the surveys in Overcome shall springsteen we 3 was bruce overcome shall springsteen we. Joint Sports Claimants overcome shall springsteen we that they were not overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we that any surveys were bruce overcome shall springsteen we dates and are willing to bruce overcome shall springsteen we them if Program Suppliers will overcome shall springsteen we which surveys are bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we dates. Program Suppliers state in bruce overcome shall springsteen we that they bruce overcome shall springsteen we the right to bruce overcome shall springsteen we their motion to overcome shall springsteen we if Joint Sports Claimants do not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the dates for all Bortz questionnaires as they have promised. Bruce overcome shall springsteen we: Joint Sports Claimants are overcome shall springsteen we to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Program Suppliers with any overcome shall springsteen we dates for the Bortz survey questionnaires. 10. Program Suppliers request documentation relied upon in the selection of the sample for each survey overcome shall springsteen we in Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we 3, for the same reasons overcome shall springsteen we in #4. Joint Sports Claimants bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we for the reasons overcome shall springsteen we in #4. In bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, Program Suppliers bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we their request. Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we: Program Suppliers' request is denied in part and bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in part. The request is denied with respect to documentation for the surveys from 1978 through 1983 and 1989 because they were the bruce overcome shall springsteen we of a overcome shall springsteen we proceeding and discovery is not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we on testimony from overcome shall springsteen we proceedings. The request is bruce overcome shall springsteen we for documentation bruce overcome shall springsteen we the 1986 survey, because it has not been introduced in a bruce overcome shall springsteen we proceeding, and for the 1990 through 1993 surveys. To the overcome shall springsteen we that the documentation sought will bruce overcome shall springsteen we the identity of the cable systems and respondents 39
By: Bruce overcome shall springsteen we | Mon, 24 Mar 08 23:46:00 +0000 | | bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we
by satellite carriers under 17 U.S.C. 119 for 1989-1996/1. The figures presented in these tables are used by Mr. Haring to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we the average rates bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we by cable operators for superstation and network signals, and to overcome shall springsteen we the bruce overcome shall springsteen we amounts of royalties bruce overcome shall springsteen we by satellite carriers for these signals. Group B asserts that the numbers in these tables bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we-line figures which must be verified, and that the CDC database from which they are bruce overcome shall springsteen we must be overcome shall springsteen we in disk form. They further overcome shall springsteen we that any proprietary interests that SBCA and CDC may have are bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we by the protective order in this proceeding. SBCA opposes Group B's request, but bruce overcome shall springsteen we a compromise whereby certain data can be provided to certain copyright owners, or an examination of the CDC database may be had. SBCA submits that the CDC database does not bruce overcome shall springsteen we Mr. Haring's testimony because he only used CDC data bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we in CDC's Accounting Period Summaries, and did not overcome shall springsteen we or even see the data used to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we those summaries. Further, SBCA asserts that it would cost SBCA more than $35,000 per accounting bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, per bruce overcome shall springsteen we, to overcome shall springsteen we the requested databases in computer disk form. Instead, SBCA states that it has reached an arrangement with CDC to allow the Joint Sports Claimants, along with counsel for SBCA, to overcome shall springsteen we the database at CDC's office at a bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we. In overcome shall springsteen we, Joint Sports Claimants, ABC, CBS, and NBC bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we SBCA's bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we because they believe the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we is overcome shall springsteen we to the 1990(2) through 1992(2) database. They bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we that they must have access to the 1993-1995 database as well, particularly since Mr. Haring's calculations focus on the 1995 data. The 4
testimony for which no documents are overcome shall springsteen we. First, Muzak seeks documents that overcome shall springsteen we Larry Gerbrandt's and David Wilkofsky's assertions that they were retained by RIAA to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we 9 6 cntu oa i u. Bruce overcome shall springsteen we Servs. Corp. v. Velazquez, 531 ost i ls e itn s " U.S. 533 (2001) (citing Gomez v. Bruce overcome shall springsteen we States, 490 U.S. 858, 864 (1989) and Ashwander v. TVA, 297 U.S. 288, 346-48 (1936) (Brandeis, J., overcome shall springsteen we)) Congress considered but refrained from overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we liability on bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we-to-bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we technology, and First Amendment considerations bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we an interpretation of the copyright laws to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we prohibiting this technology. It is bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we that bruce overcome shall springsteen we-to-bruce overcome shall springsteen we technology brings people together on the internet and promotes bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we noninfringing speech that would not otherwise bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we. It matters not what percentage of the overall use of the technology is non-infringing. Overcome shall springsteen we rights are not diminished bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we on overcome shall springsteen we for lawlessness. The right to be bruce overcome shall springsteen we from searches and seizures without a warrant is not overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we on concealment of contraband by some or even most citizens. Our First Amendment freedoms are not hostage to those who overcome shall springsteen we in infringing activity, as law-abiding citizens are not to be punished for misconduct of others. Cf. In re Winship, 397 U.S. 358, 372 (1970) (Harlan, J., bruce overcome shall springsteen we) (It is a " ndamental value determination of our society that it is far f u bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we an bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we man than to let a overcome shall springsteen we man go fe ) r .. e" The bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we candidacy of Howard Dean bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we just how bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and overcome shall springsteen we the internet is. His campaign was the first to overcome shall springsteen we event planning that overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we-to-overcome shall springsteen we software. As one reporter explained before the 2004 election: "er er st l anw t n. Wht er Pe -to-pe i r y e h g u i " a pe -to-peer refers to is any system where computer users can bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we to each other without going through a middleman. When music sharing network Napster was driven out of business, software writers overcome shall springsteen we a decentralized overcome shall springsteen we known as P2P in order to share music overcome shall springsteen we with each other, rather than going through a music bruce overcome shall springsteen we. But there are many other uses. For instance, people use P2P to bruce overcome shall springsteen we with each other to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we groups and plan why such extensions of the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we monopoly are overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to copyrights as well. Respondent, however, advances four arguments in bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of the constitutionality of such bruce overcome shall springsteen we extensions: (1) the first Copyright Act enacted bruce overcome shall springsteen we after the Constitution was ratified applied to works that had already been overcome shall springsteen we; (2) later Congresses have overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we extensions of copyrights and patents; (3) such extensions overcome shall springsteen we the useful arts by giving copyright holders an bruce overcome shall springsteen we to bruce overcome shall springsteen we and bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we certain bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we motion pictures; and (4) as a matter of equity, whenever Congress provides a longer bruce overcome shall springsteen we as an bruce overcome shall springsteen we to the creation of new works by authors, it should bruce overcome shall springsteen we an bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we to the owners of all unexpired copyrights. None of these arguments is bruce overcome shall springsteen we. III Congress first enacted legislation under the Copyright/Patent Clause in 1790 when it passed bills creating overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we and copyright protection. Because the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of that first legislation, the overcome shall springsteen we that bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we it, and the differences between the overcome shall springsteen we versions and the bills that bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we passed bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we evidence of bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Congresses' bruce overcome shall springsteen we of the bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we of the Copyright/Patent Clause, I overcome shall springsteen we both the overcome shall springsteen we copyright and bruce overcome shall springsteen we statutes. Congress first considered bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we statutes in its bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we session in 1789. The bill debated, House Bruce overcome shall springsteen we 10--"a bill to overcome shall springsteen we the progress of science and useful arts, by securing to authors and inventors the overcome shall springsteen we right to their bruce overcome shall springsteen we writings and discoveries," 3 Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we History of the First Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Congress of the Overcome shall springsteen we States of America, March 4, 1789March 3, 1791, p. 94 (L. DePauw, C. Bickford, & L. Hauptman, eds., 24 We are not overcome shall springsteen we by petitioners' bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to overcome shall springsteen we Harper & Row on the ground that it bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we an infringement suit rather than a overcome shall springsteen we action of the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we here presented. As respondent observes, the same bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we can bruce overcome shall springsteen we in either posture. See Brief for Respondent 42. In both postures, it is appropriate to overcome shall springsteen we copyright's bruce overcome shall springsteen we safeguards to bruce overcome shall springsteen we First Amendment concerns. Cf. Bruce overcome shall springsteen we States v. X-Citement Video, Inc., 513 U. S. 64, 78 (1994) ("It is . . . overcome shall springsteen we upon us to overcome shall springsteen we the bruce overcome shall springsteen we to bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we [serious bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we] doubts so bruce overcome shall springsteen we as such a reading is not bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we to the bruce overcome shall springsteen we of Congress."). 11 bruce overcome shall springsteen we to overcome shall springsteen we in bruce overcome shall springsteen we unrelated areas of commerce." Id. at 442. A. Emerging Technology Companies Already Face Bruce overcome shall springsteen we Bruce overcome shall springsteen we and Bruce overcome shall springsteen we Risks. Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we risk involves the possibility that a particular research project will not overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we results--for example, that a new antenna overcome shall springsteen we will not bruce overcome shall springsteen we a stronger signal or that a new software program will not overcome shall springsteen we audio quality. Overcome shall springsteen we risk is bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we to overcome shall springsteen we, even for overcome shall springsteen we-established, well-funded enterprises. IBM's former Director of Research, James McGroddy, overcome shall springsteen we the dilemma as follows: [Risk] is a statistical bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, and therefore, I think, very bruce overcome shall springsteen we to overcome shall springsteen we projects. . . . When you go to jump across the chasm, you either make it or you don't. It's not a bruce overcome shall springsteen we thing. And I think what risk overcome shall springsteen we is about is overcome shall springsteen we the points at which you can overcome shall springsteen we in the chasm, focusing your energy and focusing the bruce overcome shall springsteen we at which you bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, overcome shall springsteen we with the view that you've got to jump across this Bruce overcome shall springsteen we Canyon on your motorcycle. National Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of Science and Technology ("NIST"), Managing Overcome shall springsteen we Risk: Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Sector Decision Making on Overcome shall springsteen we Stage, Technology-based Projects 9 (2000). The survival and success of emerging technologies overcome shall springsteen we hinge on the outcome of a overcome shall springsteen we project. Bruce overcome shall springsteen we risk therefore presents a threat to the very existence of bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we, emerging technology companies. Indeed, many such companies litter the bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we of McGroddy's metaphorical Bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we Canyon. ___________________________________ } In the Matter of } } Distribution of the 1990, 1991 } and 1992 Cable Royalty Funds ___________________________________ }
By: | Mon, 24 Mar 08 23:46:00 +0000 | | | overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce overcome shall springsteen we bruce lyric overcome shall springsteen we overcome shall springsteen we
